| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Kelleher, Stephen P (16)
|
MRRFAC |
4:49.85 |
4:58.45 |
8.60 |
| 2 |
Trzewik-Quinn, Seamus (15)
|
ADHAWK |
5:01.38 |
4:59.27 |
-2.11 |
| 3 |
Deans-Brandt, Collin W (18)
|
MRAG |
5:11.19 |
5:08.50 |
-2.69 |
| 4 |
Boyko, Jason A (15)
|
MRRFAC |
5:04.66 |
5:13.96 |
9.30 |
| 5 |
Santiago, Christopher (16)
|
MRWSSC |
5:23.77 |
5:32.44 |
8.67 |
| 6 |
LaPorte, Leonardo F (16)
|
MRWSSC |
5:34.84 |
5:36.26 |
1.42 |
| 7 |
De Asis, Randill (17)
|
MRTRS |
6:16.10 |
5:37.81 |
-38.29 |
| 8 |
Jarski, Alexander C (15)
|
MRAG |
5:17.35 |
5:39.73 |
22.38 |
| 9 |
Smahaj, Kevin (16)
|
MRTRS |
5:55.31 |
6:06.16 |
10.85 |
| 10 |
Norbeck, Kyle (15)
|
MRCFJV |
6:32.08 |
6:18.00 |
-14.08 |