| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Pearce, Jonathan T (12)
|
NJSVY |
5:02.79 |
5:05.09 |
2.30 |
| 2 |
O'Mara, Gerald F (12)
|
NJBAC |
5:04.91 |
5:09.41 |
4.50 |
| 3 |
Stryszak, Matthew (11)
|
NJBAC |
5:13.49 |
5:11.14 |
-2.35 |
| 4 |
Halada, Christopher P (12)
|
NJSVY |
5:15.34 |
5:11.90 |
-3.44 |
| 5 |
Park, Ryan S (12)
|
NJBAC |
5:36.25 |
5:12.08 |
-24.17 |
| 6 |
Martinez, David A (12)
|
NJBAC |
5:26.33 |
5:16.17 |
-10.16 |
| 7 |
Low, Ethan D (12)
|
NJBAC |
5:30.36 |
5:18.42 |
-11.94 |
| 8 |
Rizzotto, Nicolas F (12)
|
NJBAC |
5:24.98 |
5:19.46 |
-5.52 |
| 9 |
Sartorio, Thomas J (11)
|
NJBAC |
5:35.34 |
5:19.76 |
-15.58 |
| 10 |
Baker, Roan (11)
|
NJWY |
5:30.78 |
5:22.02 |
-8.76 |
| 11 |
Lim, Andrew H (11)
|
NJBAC |
5:27.81 |
5:22.27 |
-5.54 |
| 12 |
Kuo, Mark (12)
|
NJSVY |
5:33.54 |
5:30.74 |
-2.80 |
| 13 |
Alvarez, Alessandro G (12)
|
NJEAG |
5:45.92 |
5:50.51 |
4.59 |
| 14 |
Laynez, Angel (11)
|
NJEAG |
5:40.78 |
5:53.98 |
13.20 |
| 15 |
Gold, Nicholas S (11)
|
NJBAC |
5:42.32 |
5:58.78 |
16.46 |