| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Calloni, Johannes M (15)
|
NJSCAR |
4:39.34 |
4:48.24 |
8.90 |
| 2 |
Polishchuk, Oleksiy (15)
|
NJSCAR |
5:15.71 |
5:09.30 |
-6.41 |
| 3 |
Om, John (18)
|
NJLHY |
4:58.00 |
5:10.12 |
12.12 |
| 4 |
Mallick, Shayshadri K (15)
|
NJSCAR |
5:02.32 |
5:13.24 |
10.92 |
| 5 |
Justino, Robert (18)
|
NJSCAR |
5:11.57 |
5:13.58 |
2.01 |
| 6 |
Bogomolny, Eli (15)
|
NJSCAR |
5:11.02 |
5:14.14 |
3.12 |
| 7 |
Li, Thomas H (16)
|
NJSCAR |
5:17.87 |
5:19.07 |
1.20 |
| 8 |
Nalewajek, Brian (15)
|
NJSCAR |
5:12.08 |
5:21.44 |
9.36 |
| 9 |
Morenos, Joshua M (18)
|
NJSCAR |
5:26.49 |
5:21.45 |
-5.04 |
| 10 |
Rossi, Leonardo G (16)
|
NJSCAR |
5:28.56 |
5:21.64 |
-6.92 |
| 11 |
Vanderbeek, Thomas G (18)
|
NJSCAR |
5:36.00 |
5:48.76 |
12.76 |