| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Kim, Minjeong R (14)
|
NJACE |
5:01.15 |
4:58.53 |
-2.62 |
| 2 |
Schlackman, Olivia C (18)
|
NJBB |
4:49.74 |
5:03.99 |
14.25 |
| 3 |
McLaughlin, Casey J (13)
|
NJBB |
5:00.11 |
5:08.30 |
8.19 |
| 4 |
Berg, Jillian E (14)
|
NJNJB |
5:10.36 |
5:13.89 |
3.53 |
| 5 |
Sirotic, Jacqueline A (13)
|
NJSCAR |
5:24.48 |
5:14.40 |
-10.08 |
| 6 |
Soutter, Hannah L (16)
|
NJNJB |
5:33.10 |
5:21.58 |
-11.52 |
| 7 |
Skinner, Gabriela (16)
|
NJJFAC |
5:52.25 |
5:25.90 |
-26.35 |
| 8 |
Soll, Charlotte P (14)
|
NJBB |
5:01.22 |
5:33.63 |
32.41 |
| 9 |
McIntyre, Emma L (14)
|
NJBB |
5:29.00 |
5:35.61 |
6.61 |
| 10 |
Burmaster, Caroline M (13)
|
NJBB |
6:01.22 |
5:51.91 |
-9.31 |
| 11 |
Chung, Gwendolyn (13)
|
NJJCB |
6:50.00 |
6:39.85 |
-10.15 |
|
Hutchinson, Kristy L (13)
|
NJJCB |
6:20.00 |
DQ |
- |
|
Emr, Addison B (15)
|
NJBB |
5:42.00 |
NS |
- |
|
McNerney, Julia P (15)
|
NJBB |
5:56.36 |
NS |
- |