| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Giardinelli, Josh R (16)
|
MRLIE |
4:41.31 |
4:46.13 |
4.82 |
| 2 |
Burr, Trenton H (16)
|
MRHAA |
4:54.72 |
4:50.75 |
-3.97 |
| 3 |
Casey, Jack H (17)
|
MRHAA |
4:54.41 |
4:58.92 |
4.51 |
| 4 |
Sansiviero, Burke C (17)
|
MRLIE |
5:03.10 |
5:02.38 |
-0.72 |
| 5 |
Wone, Brandon M (15)
|
MRSSC |
5:01.74 |
5:07.02 |
5.28 |
| 6 |
Weber, Christopher R (15)
|
MRLIE |
5:15.96 |
5:09.53 |
-6.43 |
| 7 |
Hunt, Andrew (16)
|
MRHAA |
5:21.66 |
5:09.91 |
-11.75 |
| 8 |
Quiceno, Sebastian A (15)
|
MRSSC |
5:25.27 |
5:19.31 |
-5.96 |
| 9 |
Lee, Joshua S (15)
|
MRBBSC |
5:22.88 |
5:23.99 |
1.11 |
| 10 |
Nielsen, Jordan (15)
|
MRHAA |
5:21.01 |
5:24.67 |
3.66 |
| 11 |
Orehosky, Bailey T (16)
|
MRHAA |
5:20.24 |
5:24.78 |
4.54 |
| 12 |
McNamara, William A (17)
|
MRBBSC |
5:41.09 |
5:32.73 |
-8.36 |
| 13 |
LaBianca, Jack B (12)
|
MRLIE |
6:10.05 |
6:03.87 |
-6.18 |
| 14 |
Freund, Jonah T (11)
|
MRLIE |
6:55.65 |
7:30.61 |
34.96 |