| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Beauchene, Alex M (16)
|
CTFVYT |
5:00.70 |
4:58.75 |
-1.95 |
| 2 |
Zuwallack, Angus W (17)
|
NECCSC |
5:02.98 |
4:59.11 |
-3.87 |
| 3 |
Louis-Charles, Frantz V (16)
|
MRYMID |
5:40.19 |
5:06.42 |
-33.77 |
| 4 |
Celaj, Ilirian (17)
|
MRYMID |
5:08.45 |
5:12.98 |
4.53 |
| 5 |
Heather, Matthew J (18)
|
NEBGSC |
5:10.59 |
5:25.26 |
14.67 |
| 6 |
Roychoudhury, Devayan (15)
|
MRYMID |
5:34.76 |
5:29.75 |
-5.01 |
| 7 |
Ni, Andrew C (17)
|
NEATST |
5:42.62 |
5:30.50 |
-12.12 |
| 8 |
Contreras, Jose A (17)
|
MRYMID |
5:38.16 |
5:33.39 |
-4.77 |
| 9 |
Burden, Miles E (16)
|
NECS |
5:38.61 |
5:39.34 |
0.73 |
| 10 |
Byrd, Nicholas G (15)
|
MRYMID |
5:50.44 |
5:39.94 |
-10.50 |
| 11 |
Wu, James (16)
|
NEABF |
5:45.49 |
5:48.85 |
3.36 |
| 12 |
Shenker, Ethan M (16)
|
NECCFF |
6:04.87 |
6:07.26 |
2.39 |