| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Zeibari, Kevork J (16)
|
MAUDAC |
5:06.29 |
4:48.94 |
-17.35 |
| 2 |
Zatonskyy, Denis (17)
|
MALMOR |
5:03.80 |
4:54.47 |
-9.33 |
| 3 |
McHugh, Ryan M (15)
|
MALMOR |
4:50.84 |
4:57.24 |
6.40 |
| 4 |
McFadden, Liam G (18)
|
MAUDAC |
4:58.68 |
4:57.99 |
-0.69 |
| 5 |
Kressman, Jared (18)
|
MAUDAC |
4:59.23 |
4:59.02 |
-0.21 |
| 6 |
Keillor, Aidan (17)
|
MAUDAC |
5:09.48 |
5:07.81 |
-1.67 |
| 7 |
Gold, Lucas A (15)
|
NJPPST |
6:20.48 |
5:09.11 |
-71.37 |
| 8 |
Marcus, Andrew (17)
|
MAUDAC |
5:18.77 |
5:11.31 |
-7.46 |
| 9 |
Portnoy, Ashton (16)
|
MAUDAC |
5:32.13 |
5:12.96 |
-19.17 |
| 10 |
Robinson, Benjamin R (16)
|
NJCJAC |
5:20.68 |
5:14.09 |
-6.59 |
| 11 |
In, Jonathan (15)
|
MAUDAC |
5:34.57 |
5:18.33 |
-16.24 |
| 12 |
Barglow, Luke W (17)
|
NJPTAC |
5:18.66 |
5:24.65 |
5.99 |
| 13 |
Laine, Benjamin R (15)
|
NJPTAC |
5:16.11 |
5:33.83 |
17.72 |
| 14 |
Gewartowski, Michael (15)
|
MAUDAC |
5:47.89 |
5:36.93 |
-10.96 |
| 15 |
Lacava, Paul M (15)
|
NJPPST |
7:07.18 |
5:48.61 |
-78.57 |