| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Isman, Daniel M (18)
|
PVNCAP |
4:51.85 |
5:01.55 |
9.70 |
| 2 |
Macmillan, Cameron A (16)
|
MDCAA |
5:01.34 |
5:05.99 |
4.65 |
| 3 |
Palmer, Curan K (15)
|
PVNCAP |
4:51.88 |
5:06.84 |
14.96 |
| 4 |
McArthur III, Jeffrey M (16)
|
MDCAA |
5:04.82 |
5:11.53 |
6.71 |
| 5 |
Berner, Zachary R (16)
|
PVAAC |
4:53.85 |
5:12.85 |
19.00 |
| 6 |
Albert, Ryan E (15)
|
PVASA |
5:28.85 |
5:14.79 |
-14.06 |
| 7 |
Hoy, Connor W (15)
|
MDCAA |
5:01.50 |
5:15.22 |
13.72 |
| 8 |
Scott, Maxwell A (15)
|
PVSDS |
5:34.97 |
5:27.72 |
-7.25 |
| 9 |
Schiffman, Parker W (15)
|
PVMAKO |
5:45.70 |
5:33.58 |
-12.12 |
| 10 |
Feinberg, Nathan G (16)
|
PVFXFX |
5:12.62 |
5:36.76 |
24.14 |
| 11 |
Riedl, Finn W (17)
|
PVNCAP |
|
5:38.74 |
- |
| 12 |
Loughmiller, Maxwell E (17)
|
PVFXFX |
5:30.76 |
5:43.77 |
13.01 |
| 13 |
Loughmiller, Benjamin M (15)
|
PVFXFX |
5:32.53 |
5:45.51 |
12.98 |
| 14 |
Galarza, Nicolas M (16)
|
PVFXFX |
|
6:00.17 |
- |
|
Thomas, Reid C (16)
|
MDCAA |
5:11.73 |
DQ |
- |