| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Camacho, Seth (16)
|
NJWY |
4:51.84 |
4:48.36 |
-3.48 |
| 2 |
Swenson, Matthew (15)
|
NJWY |
4:52.23 |
4:48.42 |
-3.81 |
| 3 |
Tedesco, Christian (14)
|
NJWY |
4:58.35 |
4:49.47 |
-8.88 |
| 4 |
Conlin, Floyd T (16)
|
NJSAY |
4:45.36 |
4:58.24 |
12.88 |
| 5 |
Rouse, Cormac J (14)
|
NJSAY |
5:38.85 |
5:04.05 |
-34.80 |
| 6 |
Walsh, Thomas Jr. (15)
|
NJWY |
5:00.46 |
5:08.28 |
7.82 |
| 7 |
Gannon, Christopher M (17)
|
NJSAY |
5:14.41 |
5:11.28 |
-3.13 |
| 8 |
Pollock, Harris C (16)
|
NJSAY |
5:23.33 |
5:14.95 |
-8.38 |
| 9 |
Nociari, Alejandro A (16)
|
NJSAY |
5:29.35 |
5:15.04 |
-14.31 |
| 10 |
Standridge, Lucas M (14)
|
NJSVY |
5:28.53 |
5:15.22 |
-13.31 |
| 11 |
Lee, Ryan (15)
|
NJWFY |
5:12.28 |
5:25.01 |
12.73 |
| 12 |
Heinze, William P (13)
|
NJWY |
5:23.90 |
5:25.27 |
1.37 |
| 13 |
Chauhan, Shreyas (13)
|
NJSAY |
|
5:56.04 |
- |
| 14 |
Tariq, Rahim S (13)
|
NJSVY |
5:57.29 |
6:02.13 |
4.84 |