| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
LeCates, Henry G (14)
|
ADCLIN |
4:52.84 |
4:59.98 |
7.14 |
| 2 |
Long, Dylan M (17)
|
NIMETS |
4:51.11 |
5:04.95 |
13.84 |
| 3 |
Tarolli, Vincent M (15)
|
NICSCI |
5:17.76 |
5:16.52 |
-1.24 |
| 4 |
Spina, Carson A (17)
|
ADCLIN |
4:58.76 |
5:18.37 |
19.61 |
| 5 |
Hiltbrand, Alexander G (17)
|
NIJETS |
5:19.54 |
5:34.06 |
14.52 |
| 6 |
Wales, Nathaniel J (13)
|
NISYCH |
5:38.20 |
5:34.95 |
-3.25 |
| 7 |
Diel, Robert M (15)
|
NISYCH |
5:37.70 |
5:42.89 |
5.19 |
| 8 |
Carr, Cameron M (17)
|
NISYCH |
5:20.81 |
5:45.05 |
24.24 |
| 9 |
Cole, Matthew J (13)
|
NIOLSC |
6:31.89 |
6:31.27 |
-0.62 |
| 10 |
Netto, Caleb M (15)
|
NIJETS |
6:50.86 |
6:34.54 |
-16.32 |
| 11 |
Griffin, Andrew R (15)
|
NIJETS |
7:28.27 |
6:35.65 |
-52.62 |
| 12 |
Merrick, Christopher A (14)
|
NIJETS |
6:24.90 |
6:39.19 |
14.29 |
| 13 |
Walz, Nathan A (13)
|
NISYCH |
7:00.55 |
6:42.21 |
-18.34 |