| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Bowen, Daniel D (15)
|
NITWST |
4:52.19 |
4:58.40 |
6.21 |
| 2 |
Chapman, Thomas C (16)
|
NIVICT |
4:59.25 |
4:58.87 |
-0.38 |
| 3 |
Maurer, Michael O (17)
|
NISTAR |
4:45.29 |
5:02.63 |
17.34 |
| 4 |
Crist, Brandon T (16)
|
NIVICT |
5:47.77 |
5:02.92 |
-44.85 |
| 5 |
Regelsberger, Tyler R (17)
|
NIVICT |
5:23.24 |
5:15.00 |
-8.24 |
| 6 |
McLaughlin, Riley T (18)
|
NISTAR |
4:59.80 |
5:17.99 |
18.19 |
| 7 |
Walters, Zachary J (15)
|
NITWST |
5:30.27 |
5:22.04 |
-8.23 |
| 8 |
Baker, Troy J (17)
|
NIVICT |
5:35.41 |
5:22.27 |
-13.14 |
| 9 |
D'Alessandro, Kai J (14)
|
NIVICT |
5:28.39 |
5:25.51 |
-2.88 |
| 10 |
Matteson, Carter J (16)
|
NISTAR |
5:12.86 |
5:25.65 |
12.79 |
| 11 |
De Livera, Avishka J (15)
|
NIUN-D |
5:20.00 |
5:25.92 |
5.92 |
| 12 |
Hewett, Ian R (13)
|
NIBAAC |
5:29.99 |
5:26.01 |
-3.98 |
| 13 |
Staples, Graeme A (15)
|
NISTAR |
5:24.66 |
5:30.13 |
5.47 |
| 14 |
El Shamy, Aly S (12)
|
NIUN-D |
5:35.00 |
5:30.22 |
-4.78 |
| 15 |
Strittmatter, Blaise A (14)
|
NISTAR |
5:45.38 |
5:44.91 |
-0.47 |
| 16 |
Smith, Connor J (13)
|
NIVICT |
6:20.86 |
5:54.79 |
-26.07 |
| 17 |
Chapman, Jack E (13)
|
NIVICT |
5:51.02 |
6:01.03 |
10.01 |
| 18 |
Bouton, Matthew R (13)
|
NIBAAC |
6:08.15 |
6:13.43 |
5.28 |
| 19 |
Domster, Aidan M (12)
|
NISTAR |
|
7:44.79 |
- |