| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Teixeira, Anthony J (16)
|
NISKAN |
4:49.09 |
4:54.97 |
5.88 |
| 2 |
Tarolli, Vincent M (15)
|
NICSCI |
5:31.02 |
5:17.76 |
-13.26 |
| 3 |
Thomas, Joshua D (17)
|
NIOLSC |
5:14.13 |
5:21.86 |
7.73 |
| 4 |
Nowicki, Justin J (13)
|
NISKAN |
5:16.39 |
5:25.27 |
8.88 |
| 5 |
Spaulding, Hana E (14)
|
NISKAN |
5:28.33 |
5:25.80 |
-2.53 |
| 6 |
Wells, Ben A (15)
|
NISKAN |
5:21.75 |
5:27.92 |
6.17 |
| 7 |
Kabunov, Mikhail V (12)
|
NIUN-N |
5:26.25 |
5:39.05 |
12.80 |
| 8 |
Miranda, Tristan A (15)
|
NIUN-N |
5:55.21 |
5:43.63 |
-11.58 |
| 9 |
Licciardello, John T (17)
|
NIJETS |
4:58.41 |
5:50.88 |
52.47 |
| 10 |
Van Kersbergen, Gavin M (11)
|
NIUN-S |
|
5:55.59 |
- |
| 11 |
Matthews, Arianna E (11)
|
NISKAN |
6:22.45 |
6:07.77 |
-14.68 |
| 12 |
Alexander, Nathan R (12)
|
NIJETS |
6:39.62 |
6:20.15 |
-19.47 |
| 13 |
Thompson, Kaitlyn G (11)
|
NIJETS |
6:55.36 |
6:21.72 |
-33.64 |
| 14 |
Cole, Matthew J (13)
|
NIOLSC |
6:40.85 |
6:31.89 |
-8.96 |
|
Loomis, Jesse J (13)
|
NIMETS |
|
DQ |
- |