| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Makarov, Aleksey (17)
|
MRNBS |
5:11.96 |
5:06.40 |
-5.56 |
| 2 |
Whitfield, George (18)
|
MRNYCC |
5:15.06 |
5:13.34 |
-1.72 |
| 3 |
Roldan-Vasco, Mateo (17)
|
CTZEUS |
4:52.15 |
5:23.22 |
31.07 |
| 4 |
Dauser, Chris M (15)
|
CTZEUS |
5:16.76 |
5:28.52 |
11.76 |
| 5 |
Samsonov, Luka A (14)
|
MRNBS |
5:26.67 |
5:31.19 |
4.52 |
| 6 |
Looney, Ryan T (17)
|
CTZEUS |
5:12.06 |
5:32.98 |
20.92 |
| 7 |
Parizot, Louis-Maximilia (16)
|
CTZEUS |
5:18.32 |
5:40.29 |
21.97 |
| 8 |
ZHANG, JOHN (13)
|
MRNCAC |
5:23.00 |
5:41.10 |
18.10 |
| 9 |
Fedor, AJ (16)
|
CTZEUS |
5:51.51 |
5:48.65 |
-2.86 |
| 10 |
Parizot, Paul-Alexander (17)
|
CTZEUS |
5:17.79 |
5:50.11 |
32.32 |
| 11 |
Spring, Eli N (14)
|
MRBKR |
5:55.01 |
6:03.23 |
8.22 |
| 12 |
Gash, Richard W (15)
|
MRPATS |
6:09.11 |
6:11.77 |
2.66 |
| 13 |
Colistra, Giancarlo W (13)
|
CTZEUS |
6:02.23 |
6:12.25 |
10.02 |
| 14 |
Zullo, Lorenzo R (13)
|
CTZEUS |
6:10.92 |
6:15.84 |
4.92 |
| 15 |
Cunniffe, Finn (13)
|
CTZEUS |
6:12.00 |
6:19.08 |
7.08 |
| 16 |
Wallace, John W (14)
|
MRBKR |
6:40.00 |
7:11.36 |
31.36 |
| 17 |
Burns, Trevor (16)
|
MRBKR |
6:05.37 |
DQ |
- |
| 18 |
Vasilkoff, Daniel (15)
|
MRNYCC |
5:23.60 |
NS |
- |