| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Oster, Madison G (18)
|
MADST |
4:32.11 |
4:41.66 |
9.55 |
| 1 |
Berry, Jessica L (16)
|
MDFSC |
|
5:15.43 |
- |
| 1 |
Carlozzi, Josephine M (17)
|
MABRY |
5:42.33 |
5:46.33 |
4.00 |
| 2 |
Barbieri, Gabriella M (16)
|
MABRY |
5:03.32 |
5:00.97 |
-2.35 |
| 2 |
Jones, Megan E (15)
|
MAWAC |
5:31.45 |
5:26.50 |
-4.95 |
| 3 |
Kilama, Atim (15)
|
MABRY |
5:03.09 |
5:01.44 |
-1.65 |
| 3 |
Pepe, Alexandrea R (15)
|
MAWAC |
5:26.18 |
5:27.47 |
1.29 |
| 4 |
Thomas, Allison K (16)
|
MABRY |
4:47.42 |
5:01.49 |
14.07 |
| 4 |
Donohue, Nicole B (15)
|
MDFSC |
6:46.76 |
5:28.85 |
-77.91 |
| 5 |
Balbo, Megan E (15)
|
NJCAT |
4:56.01 |
5:04.39 |
8.38 |
| 6 |
Green, Rebecca A (16)
|
MABRY |
4:52.58 |
5:07.86 |
15.28 |
|
Fabbri, Alexandra M (18)
|
MATHY |
4:39.62 |
DQ |
- |