| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Swenson, Matthew (14)
|
NJWY |
4:33.97 |
4:37.64 |
3.67 |
| 2 |
Rampaul-Pino, Andrew R (14)
|
NJSVY |
4:43.55 |
4:40.07 |
-3.48 |
| 3 |
Townson, Connor G (14)
|
NJMYM |
4:54.66 |
4:43.47 |
-11.19 |
| 4 |
Trenery, Aidan (14)
|
NJFSPY |
4:42.70 |
4:49.42 |
6.72 |
| 5 |
Remache, Cristian G (14)
|
NJMYM |
5:01.83 |
5:04.32 |
2.49 |
| 6 |
Rodriguez-LaLlave, Jose A (13)
|
NJMYM |
5:16.77 |
5:05.65 |
-11.12 |
| 7 |
Powers, Leo A (13)
|
NJMYM |
5:26.38 |
5:05.66 |
-20.72 |
| 8 |
Negron, Dylan A (14)
|
NJFSPY |
5:05.24 |
5:11.01 |
5.77 |
| 9 |
Goldman, Brenden W (14)
|
NJMYM |
5:27.39 |
5:25.40 |
-1.99 |
| 10 |
Habjan, Ian M (13)
|
NJMYM |
5:27.39 |
5:33.61 |
6.22 |