| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Zhang, Jia Z (12)
|
NJPTAC |
5:17.17 |
4:51.05 |
-26.12 |
| 2 |
Rodricks, Sebastian M (12)
|
NJXCEL |
4:48.87 |
4:53.03 |
4.16 |
| 3 |
McWha, Liam C (12)
|
NJPTAC |
5:24.07 |
4:53.35 |
-30.72 |
| 4 |
Hall, Kevin J (12)
|
NJRVYM |
5:07.98 |
5:25.01 |
17.03 |
| 5 |
Soukhanovskii, Nikolai A (11)
|
NJPTAC |
5:38.82 |
5:29.03 |
-9.79 |
| 6 |
Lu, Jasper (12)
|
NJXCEL |
5:28.45 |
5:34.18 |
5.73 |
| 7 |
Bhatia, Josh (12)
|
NJWY |
5:48.56 |
5:36.34 |
-12.22 |
| 8 |
Brogan, Andreas S (12)
|
NJWW |
5:59.09 |
5:37.51 |
-21.58 |
| 9 |
Ricciardi, Nathan E (12)
|
NJPPST |
5:46.49 |
5:52.31 |
5.82 |
| 10 |
Atkins, Dylan L (12)
|
NJPTAC |
6:00.09 |
6:06.07 |
5.98 |
| 11 |
Das, Rayan (11)
|
NJPTAC |
6:00.09 |
6:15.13 |
15.04 |