| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Chapman, Thomas C (17)
|
NIVICT |
4:47.35 |
4:50.87 |
3.52 |
| 2 |
Kreiley, Aidan C (16)
|
NIMERC |
4:42.77 |
4:55.80 |
13.03 |
| 3 |
Li, Shoonhsin S (17)
|
NIKRKN |
5:08.00 |
4:59.69 |
-8.31 |
| 4 |
Ludlow, Benjamin L (17)
|
NIMERC |
4:55.69 |
5:03.33 |
7.64 |
| 5 |
Hall, Sawyer J (16)
|
NIVICT |
5:27.85 |
5:19.82 |
-8.03 |
| 6 |
Smith, Connor J (15)
|
NIVICT |
5:11.22 |
5:28.17 |
16.95 |
| 7 |
Morreale, Alexander H (15)
|
NIHAST |
5:24.37 |
5:33.53 |
9.16 |
| 8 |
Michalowski, Connor J (16)
|
NIHAST |
5:25.50 |
5:38.16 |
12.66 |
| 9 |
Ciravola, Jayden T (15)
|
NIHAST |
5:54.19 |
6:05.73 |
11.54 |
| 10 |
DiBitetto, Jack J (16)
|
NIHAST |
5:39.16 |
6:19.42 |
40.26 |
| 11 |
Wilson, Kyle J (16)
|
NIHAST |
6:30.89 |
6:38.73 |
7.84 |