| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Mueller, Jackson S (14)
|
VANOVA |
4:57.92 |
4:49.67 |
-8.25 |
| 2 |
Mayr, Charlie T (14)
|
VANOVA |
4:59.04 |
4:49.81 |
-9.23 |
| 3 |
Szobota, Nathan M (13)
|
VANOVA |
5:08.30 |
5:02.13 |
-6.17 |
| 4 |
Conner, Joseph H (14)
|
VANOVA |
5:08.93 |
5:04.27 |
-4.66 |
| 5 |
Kennedy, Ethan J (14)
|
VANOVA |
5:26.24 |
5:23.50 |
-2.74 |
| 6 |
Ridge, Spencer M (14)
|
VANOVA |
5:19.11 |
5:24.41 |
5.30 |
| 7 |
Shanfield, Charles E (14)
|
PVNCAP |
5:39.28 |
5:32.50 |
-6.78 |
| 8 |
Houston-Henderson, Grayson H (14)
|
PVNCAP |
|
5:34.28 |
- |
| 9 |
Rudin, Alexander J (14)
|
PVNCAP |
5:47.40 |
5:38.46 |
-8.94 |
| 10 |
LeFaivre, James R (13)
|
PVNCAP |
7:14.96 |
6:15.92 |
-59.04 |