| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Henry, Drew (18)
|
MANRG |
4:35.64 |
4:42.24 |
6.60 |
| 2 |
DeMarco, Joshua D (15)
|
NJEEX |
4:51.73 |
4:51.71 |
-0.02 |
| 3 |
Nier, Lukas D (17)
|
MAGSA |
5:08.48 |
4:53.27 |
-15.21 |
| 4 |
Nicolai, Alexander J (17)
|
MAGSA |
4:51.48 |
4:58.33 |
6.85 |
| 5 |
DeSopo, Nicholas C (13)
|
NJRSA |
5:15.24 |
5:12.40 |
-2.84 |
| 6 |
Elzawawy, Kareem (13)
|
NJLIFE |
5:20.85 |
5:13.20 |
-7.65 |
| 7 |
Hernandez, Jonathan F (14)
|
NJSCAR |
5:10.82 |
5:15.39 |
4.57 |
| 8 |
Friends, Curtis (12)
|
NJLIFE |
5:35.53 |
5:20.93 |
-14.60 |
| 9 |
Collins, Brayden C (13)
|
NJEEX |
5:20.87 |
5:21.95 |
1.08 |
| 10 |
Shao, Kenny J (15)
|
NJSCAR |
5:32.35 |
5:25.99 |
-6.36 |
| 11 |
Rodricks, Sebastian M (12)
|
NJXCEL |
5:39.10 |
5:38.46 |
-0.64 |
| 12 |
Sobanski, Max M (13)
|
NJNJRC |
5:38.38 |
5:44.57 |
6.19 |
| 13 |
Portelli, Dylan (15)
|
NJEEX |
5:53.62 |
5:56.66 |
3.04 |
| 14 |
Zlotchew, Garik (12)
|
NJXCEL |
5:50.44 |
6:03.67 |
13.23 |
| 15 |
Juwana, Lucas J (12)
|
NJSCAR |
6:19.99 |
6:08.95 |
-11.04 |
| 16 |
Lake, Roland (13)
|
NJSTAC |
6:19.84 |
6:23.89 |
4.05 |